Skip to content
The Evergreen Edit
Save app to home screen
Real Estate

HELOC vs. Home Equity Loan vs. Cash-Out Refinance: How to Compare Them, With Worked Examples

Three ways to borrow against your home, compared side by side with real math on a $40,000 project, plus the risks, fees and tax rules to check before you sign.

By Kiara Miller, Founder & Editor

Published · Last reviewed: · 9 min read

A miter saw and ear protection set up on a workbench outside a brick house during a home renovation project
Photo: Taduuda via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

All three let you turn home equity into cash, but they price risk very differently, and the cheapest-looking option isn't always the cheapest over time.

What is the difference between a HELOC, a home equity loan and a cash-out refinance?

A home equity loan gives you one lump sum at a fixed rate. A HELOC is a reusable credit line, usually with a variable rate. A cash-out refinance replaces your whole mortgage with a bigger one and hands you the difference. All three use your home as collateral, so missed payments can put the house at risk.

That last point is the one to keep in front of you the whole way through. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts it plainly for HELOCs: if you fall behind or can't repay on schedule, "you could lose your home." The same is true of a home equity loan and a cash-out refinance. Credit card debt can hurt your credit score. Home equity debt can cost you the roof over your head.

First, figure out how much equity you can actually borrow

Equity is your home's value minus what you owe on it. Lenders don't let you borrow all of it. They look at the combined loan-to-value ratio, or CLTV, which is every loan secured by the home divided by the home's appraised value. Each lender sets its own maximum, so ask for the number before you apply.

Here is the household we will use for every example in this guide. Maya and Jordan own a home that appraises at $400,000. They owe $240,000 on a mortgage at 3.5% with 25 years left, and their monthly principal and interest payment is about $1,201.50. Their equity is $160,000, or 40% of the home's value.

Say their lender caps CLTV at 80%. That means total loans on the house can't go above $320,000 (80% of $400,000). Subtract the $240,000 they already owe, and the most they could borrow is $80,000. They want $40,000 to redo their kitchen, so they fit comfortably under the cap with room to spare.

For a cash-out refinance on a one-unit primary home, Fannie Mae's eligibility matrix sets a standard maximum loan-to-value of 80% for loans run through its automated underwriting system. That is a useful benchmark, but rules differ for other loan types and properties, so confirm the limit with your lender.

Option 1: The home equity loan (fixed payment, lump sum)

A home equity loan works like a second mortgage. The CFPB says you receive the money "as a lump sum," and the loan "usually has a fixed interest rate–one that will not change." Your monthly payment stays the same until the loan is paid off, which makes budgeting simple. Home equity loans may also carry upfront fees and closing costs.

Worked example: Maya and Jordan borrow $40,000 for 15 years. To keep the math concrete, assume a fixed rate of 8.5%. (This is an illustration, not a quote. Check current offers from several lenders.) Their payment would be about $393.90 a month. Over the full 15 years, they would pay roughly $30,901 in interest.

Their total housing payment becomes about $1,595.40 a month: the original $1,201.50 mortgage plus the $393.90 equity loan. Their 3.5% first mortgage stays untouched, which matters a lot in the comparison below.

A home equity loan tends to fit a project with a known price tag, like a roof replacement or a kitchen with a signed contractor bid. The trade-off is that you start paying interest on the full $40,000 on day one, even if the contractor bills you in stages.

Option 2: The HELOC (flexible line, variable rate)

A home equity line of credit lets you borrow repeatedly against your equity, up to a credit limit, during a set window called the draw period. According to the CFPB, the draw period "could last 10 years, for example," and the lender may then set a schedule so you repay the full balance, "often over ten or 20 years." In some cases, the CFPB warns, you may have to repay the whole amount as soon as the repayment period begins, which is called a balloon payment.

HELOC rates usually float. The CFPB's HELOC brochure explains that the rate is built from an index, such as the U.S. prime rate, plus a margin the lender adds on top. When the index rises, your payment rises too. Some lenders also offer a temporarily discounted teaser rate, so look at what the rate becomes after the promotion ends.

Worked example: Maya and Jordan open a $40,000 HELOC. Assume a starting rate of 8% and an agreement that allows interest-only payments during the draw period. If they draw the full $40,000, their interest-only payment would be about $266.67 a month. That looks cheaper than the home equity loan, but none of it pays down the balance.

Now say the index climbs and their rate rises to 10%. The interest-only payment jumps to about $333.33. When the draw period ends and they must repay the $40,000 over 20 years at 10%, the payment rises to about $386.01. If rates had fallen back to 8% by then, it would be about $334.58. The HELOC's real cost depends on a rate path nobody can predict.

The flexibility is the main appeal. If the kitchen is built in stages, they can draw $15,000 for cabinets in March and $25,000 for counters and appliances in June, paying interest only on what they have drawn. A HELOC can also serve as a backstop for big, irregular costs. Just know the line isn't guaranteed: the CFPB notes that the lender might freeze your ability to take out more money if your finances change, and might not allow more borrowing if your home's value drops significantly.

Option 3: The cash-out refinance (one new, bigger mortgage)

A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one. In the CFPB brochure's words, "You replace your existing mortgage with a bigger mortgage and take the difference in cash." The brochure also notes that closing costs are generally higher than for a home equity loan or HELOC, because you are taking out a whole new first mortgage. Our guide to mortgage closing costs breaks down what those fees usually include.

Worked example: Maya and Jordan refinance their $240,000 balance into a new $280,000, 30-year mortgage and take $40,000 in cash. Assume a 7% rate for illustration. Their new principal and interest payment would be about $1,862.85 a month.

Compare that with keeping the 3.5% mortgage and adding the home equity loan: about $1,595.40 a month. The cash-out refinance costs about $267 more every month, before counting its higher closing costs. And it restarts the clock at 30 years when they had 25 left. The reason is simple. The refinance doesn't just charge 7% on the new $40,000. It also reprices the existing $240,000 from 3.5% to 7%.

The math can flip the other way. If your current mortgage rate is higher than today's refinance rates, a cash-out refinance can lower your rate on the existing balance and get you cash at the same time. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide also has seasoning rules: for its loans, a first mortgage being paid off generally must be at least 12 months old. Our guide on when to refinance your mortgage covers the break-even math in more detail.

The three side by side

Here is how the options stack up for Maya and Jordan's $40,000, using the illustrative rates above. The home equity loan adds a fixed $393.90 a month for 15 years and leaves the 3.5% mortgage alone, for a total of about $1,595.40. The HELOC starts near $266.67 a month in interest-only payments at 8%, rises to $333.33 if the rate hits 10%, and later moves to a repayment schedule that could top $386 a month. The cash-out refinance puts everything into one payment of about $1,862.85 for 30 years and gives up the 3.5% rate.

A few patterns hold up beyond this example:

  1. If you have a low first-mortgage rate, a home equity loan or HELOC usually keeps more of that advantage than a cash-out refinance.
  2. If you need a fixed, predictable payment, a home equity loan or a fixed-rate refinance gives you that. A HELOC usually doesn't, because its rate typically floats with an index.
  3. If the project cost is uncertain or spread over months, a HELOC lets you borrow only what you use.
  4. If your current mortgage rate is above today's rates, a cash-out refinance deserves a closer look.

For more on how fixed and floating rates behave over time, see our explainer on fixed vs. adjustable-rate mortgages.

Costs, rules and fine print to check before you sign

Fees vary widely, so get them in writing. The CFPB says lenders can charge certain fees when you open a HELOC, and some require minimum draws or minimum balances. Home equity loans may carry upfront fees and closing costs, and a cash-out refinance comes with full mortgage closing costs. Ask each lender for an itemized estimate so you can compare the true cost, not just the rate.

You also get a short window to change your mind. The CFPB's HELOC brochure says you can cancel the credit line in the first three days, and the lender must then cancel the loan and return the fees you paid. Use those days to reread the terms.

Selling your home ends the arrangement. The CFPB notes that if you sell, you are generally required to pay off your HELOC in full right away. Factor that into your plans if you might move within a few years.

Taxes are the last piece. Under IRS Publication 936, interest on home equity loans and lines of credit is deductible only if the money is used to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, and only if you itemize. Using a HELOC to pay off credit cards or buy a car doesn't qualify. Total mortgage debt limits also apply, and they can change, so check the current edition of Publication 936 or ask a tax professional before counting on a deduction.

A simple checklist for comparing offers

Start by writing down exactly how much you need and when you need it. Then gather quotes for at least two of the three options from several lenders on the same day, since rates move. For each quote, record the rate (and for a HELOC, the index, margin, any rate caps and what happens after a teaser rate ends), all fees, the term, and the monthly payment at today's rate and at a rate 2 points higher. Finally, add your current mortgage payment to each option so you are comparing total monthly housing costs, the way we did for Maya and Jordan.

If the higher-rate payment would strain your budget, that is useful information. A smaller loan, a longer savings runway or a phased project may be the better fit.

Frequently asked questions

Is a HELOC or a home equity loan better?

It depends on how you'll use the money. A home equity loan suits a one-time cost and gives a fixed payment, while a HELOC suits costs spread over time but usually has a variable rate that can raise your payment.

How much can I borrow against my home?

Lenders cap the combined loan-to-value ratio, which is all loans on the home divided by its appraised value. For example, at an 80% cap on a $400,000 home with a $240,000 mortgage, the most you could borrow is $80,000.

Is HELOC interest tax deductible?

Only if you itemize and use the money to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, according to IRS Publication 936. Debt limits apply, so check the current rules.

Can a lender freeze my HELOC?

Yes. The CFPB says a lender may freeze or reduce your line if your financial situation changes or your home's value drops significantly.

Content on The Evergreen Edit is for educational and informational purposes only and is not individualized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Learn more.

Which money-saving habit will you focus on next?

This article is for educational purposes only and isn't personalized financial, tax or legal advice. Consider talking with a qualified professional about your situation.

Kiara Miller

Kiara Miller — Founder & Editor

Kiara Miller is the founder and editor of The Evergreen Edit. He has been doing independent finance research for two decades, is a tax preparer, and reviews every article before it's published.

More about Kiara →

Get smarter about your money.

Join readers who get money stories on their chosen topics, daily or as new articles post.

Which topics do you want in your inbox? Pick up to 3
Email frequency

We'll use your answers to send articles you care about and to plan new content. We never sell your info. Privacy Policy

Recommended reading