Two offers, two salaries, one obvious winner? Not always. Once you count the benefits, the smaller paycheck can turn out to be the bigger deal.
How do you compare two job offers fairly?
Compare job offers by total compensation, not salary alone. Start with base pay, add the employer's 401(k) match and any bonus you can count on, subtract what you'd pay for health insurance, and put a dollar value on paid time off. The offer with the higher total, adjusted for vesting and commute, usually wins.
Benefits are a bigger slice of pay than most people realize. In its Employer Costs for Employee Compensation report released Sept. 9, 2026, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said private industry employers spent an average of $46.89 per hour worked on compensation in June 2026. Wages and salaries averaged $32.82 and "accounted for 70.0 percent of employer costs," while benefits averaged $14.07 and made up "the remaining 30.0 percent."
That doesn't mean every job's benefits are worth 30% of its salary to you. Some of that money goes to things like Social Security and Medicare taxes that every employer pays. But it shows why two jobs with similar salaries can be worth very different amounts once you look at the whole package.
Step 1: Line up the pieces side by side
Before doing any math, get every offer's details in writing. If something isn't in the offer letter, ask the recruiter or HR for the benefits summary. Here's what to collect for each job:
- Base salary, and how often raises are reviewed.
- Bonus or commission: is it guaranteed, or based on performance?
- 401(k) or other retirement plan: the match formula and the vesting schedule.
- Health insurance: your monthly premium for the coverage level you need, plus the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum.
- Paid time off: vacation, sick days and paid holidays.
- Other perks with real dollar value: commuter benefits, tuition help, remote-work stipends or equipment.
- Location and schedule: the commute, or whether the job is remote or hybrid.
Write each item down in the same order for both offers. Seeing them next to each other makes the differences jump out, and it gives you a list of questions if anything is missing.
Worked example: a $70,000 offer vs. a $76,000 offer
Let's compare two hypothetical offers for someone we'll call Jordan. These numbers are made up to show the method, so plug in your own.
Offer A pays $70,000. It matches 100% of what Jordan contributes to the 401(k), up to 4% of salary. Jordan's share of the health premium is $120 a month, and the job comes with 20 days of paid time off.
Offer B pays $76,000. It has no 401(k) match. Jordan's health premium share is $260 a month, and the job comes with 12 days of paid time off.
At first glance, Offer B looks $6,000 better. Here's the math once the benefits are counted:
- Offer A: $70,000 salary + $2,800 match (4% of $70,000, if Jordan contributes at least 4%) − $1,440 in health premiums ($120 × 12) = $71,360.
- Offer B: $76,000 salary + $0 match − $3,120 in health premiums ($260 × 12) = $72,880.
After counting the match and premiums, Offer B's lead shrinks from $6,000 to $1,520. Now add paid time off. Offer A has 8 more days off. One simple way to value a day off is your daily pay: $70,000 divided by 260 workdays is about $269 a day. Eight extra days are worth about $2,154.
With paid time off included, Offer A comes out roughly $634 ahead, even though its salary is $6,000 lower. That's not a rounding error. It flips the decision.
Bonuses deserve the same careful treatment. A guaranteed signing bonus is easy to count, but spread it over the years you expect to stay, so a $5,000 signing bonus at a job you'd keep for two years is worth about $2,500 a year. A performance bonus is less certain. Ask how much of the target bonus people in the role actually received in recent years, and count only the part you're confident about. If an offer leans heavily on a bonus you might not get, the steadier salary of the other offer may be worth more than it looks on paper.
Step 2: Check the vesting schedule
A 401(k) match is only fully yours once it vests, meaning you've worked there long enough to keep it if you leave. The money you put in yourself is always yours. The IRS puts it this way in an example: an employee's "elective deferrals, however, are always 100% vested."
Employer matching money can take longer. According to the IRS, the slowest schedules a plan may use are a 3-year cliff, where matching contributions "must be 100% vested when a participant completes 3 years of service," or a 6-year graded schedule. Under the graded schedule, you keep 0% before 2 years of service, 20% at 2 years, 40% at 3, 60% at 4, 80% at 5 and 100% at 6. Plans may vest faster, including right away, and the IRS notes that some safe harbor plans must vest matching contributions immediately.
Back to Jordan. If Offer A's match vests over six years and Jordan leaves after two, Jordan would keep only 20% of the match. Two years of $2,800 matches is $5,600, and 20% of that is $1,120. In that case, the match is worth far less than the $2,800 a year in our example. If Jordan expects to stay five years or more, or if the match vests immediately, the full value counts.
So ask: "What is the vesting schedule for the employer match?" The answer can change which offer is worth more.
Step 3: Weigh health coverage beyond the premium
The monthly premium is only part of what health insurance costs. A plan with a low premium can have a high deductible, which is what you pay before the plan starts covering most care. A plan with a higher premium might cover more from day one.
If you rarely see a doctor, the lower-premium plan may be cheaper for you. If you have ongoing prescriptions, a chronic condition or a baby on the way, a plan with a lower deductible and out-of-pocket maximum could save you more than the premium difference. Ask each employer for the plan summary and estimate your likely yearly cost: premiums plus the care you expect to use.
Also check whether either plan pairs with a health savings account, and whether the employer adds money to it. An employer HSA contribution is real money that belongs in your total, just like a 401(k) match.
Step 4: Count the commute and other costs of taking the job
A job that pays more but adds an hour of driving a day can quietly cost you thousands in gas, wear on your car, parking and time. Remote and hybrid roles can do the opposite. Our worked example on the true cost of a commute shows how to put a yearly dollar figure on it, so you can subtract it from the offer that comes with the longer drive.
Other costs to consider include work clothes, childcare changes and moving costs. If a company offers a relocation package or a signing bonus, ask whether you'd have to repay it if you leave within a certain time.
Step 5: Use the math to negotiate
Once you have a side-by-side total, you can negotiate with numbers instead of feelings. If you prefer Offer A for its benefits but Offer B's salary is higher, you could ask Offer A to close part of the gap. Or you could ask Offer B for more paid time off or a signing bonus to make up for the missing match.
Keep the request specific and polite. For example: "I'm excited about this role. Counting the 401(k) match and health premiums, the other offer comes out about $1,500 higher. Is there flexibility on base salary?" Our guide on how to negotiate a job offer covers scripts and timing.
Numbers aren't everything, of course. Growth opportunities, the manager you'd work for, job security and how much you'd enjoy the work matter too. But knowing the true dollar difference helps you decide how much those other factors are worth to you.
Frequently asked questions
What should I include when comparing job offers?
Include base salary, reliable bonuses, the 401(k) match, health insurance premiums and deductibles, paid time off, commute costs and any perks with a clear dollar value.
How do I put a dollar value on paid time off?
Divide the annual salary by 260 workdays to get a daily rate, then multiply by the difference in days off. On a $70,000 salary, each extra day is worth about $269.
Is my 401(k) match mine right away?
Not always. Your own contributions are always 100% vested, but the IRS allows employer matches to vest over up to 3 years (cliff) or 6 years (graded), so ask for the plan's schedule.
How big a share of pay do benefits make up?
In June 2026, benefits averaged $14.07 per hour worked and made up 30.0% of private industry employers' compensation costs, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Content on The Evergreen Edit is for educational and informational purposes only and is not individualized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Learn more.
Which money-saving habit will you focus on next?
This article is for educational purposes only and isn't personalized financial, tax or legal advice. Consider talking with a qualified professional about your situation.

Kiara Miller — Founder & Editor
Kiara Miller is the founder and editor of The Evergreen Edit. He has been doing independent finance research for two decades, is a tax preparer, and reviews every article before it's published.
More about Kiara →Get smarter about your money.
Join readers who get money stories on their chosen topics, daily or as new articles post.



