Skip to content
The Evergreen Edit
Save app to home screen
Financial Independence

Roth Conversions Explained: How Converting a Traditional IRA Works, What It Costs in Tax and the Five-Year Rule, With Worked Examples

A Roth conversion moves pre-tax IRA money into a Roth IRA in exchange for a tax bill now. Here is how the tax is figured, why withholding can backfire, how the five-year rule works and when the math favors converting.

By Kiara Miller, Founder & Editor

Published · Last reviewed: · 10 min read

Close-up of a desktop calculator keypad with +TAX, -TAX and RATE keys, the kind of math a Roth conversion tax estimate starts with
Photo: Joe lope via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Converting pre-tax retirement money to a Roth IRA trades a tax bill today for tax-free withdrawals later, and the details decide whether that trade works for you.

What is a Roth conversion?

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA (or another pre-tax account) into a Roth IRA. You pay ordinary income tax on any pre-tax dollars you convert, in the year you convert them. After that, the money can grow, and qualified withdrawals from the Roth come out tax-free. There is no income limit.

This guide is for savers working toward financial independence who keep hearing about conversions and want to understand the mechanics before talking to a tax professional. It covers how the tax is calculated, the rules that trip people up, and six worked examples with the math shown. The examples use round, made-up numbers. Tax brackets and limits change, so check the current figures on irs.gov before running your own numbers.

How a conversion works

The IRS puts it plainly in its IRA FAQs on rollovers and Roth conversions: "A conversion to a Roth IRA results in taxation of any untaxed amounts in the traditional IRA." The conversion is reported on Form 8606, Nondeductible IRAs, with your tax return.

You can convert all of an account or just part of it, and you can convert in more than one year. A conversion can be done as a direct transfer between two financial institutions, as a transfer within the same institution, or as a rollover, where you receive the money and deposit it into a Roth IRA within 60 days. The direct routes are simpler because nothing is withheld along the way.

Three rules shape every conversion:

  • Income doesn't matter. The IRS's Topic 309 says that regardless of the amount of your adjusted gross income, you may be able to convert amounts from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. The income limits you may have heard about apply to direct Roth contributions, not conversions.
  • There is no undo button. Conversions made after 2017 can't be recharacterized, or reversed back into a traditional IRA. Once you convert, the tax bill is locked in, even if the market drops the next day.
  • Required minimum distributions can't be converted. If you are old enough to take required minimum distributions, the amount you're required to withdraw for the year isn't eligible for rollover, so it has to come out first. Only money above that amount can be converted.

The usual once-a-year limit on IRA-to-IRA rollovers doesn't apply to conversions, according to the IRS page on rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions, so you can do several in the same year.

Why people convert

The basic case for converting is a bet on tax rates. If you expect your tax rate in retirement to be the same as or higher than it is now, paying the tax today can come out ahead. If you expect a lower rate later, leaving the money in a pre-tax account usually wins.

That's why many people on the path to financial independence look at conversions in years when their income is unusually low: a gap year between jobs, a sabbatical, or the early years of retirement before Social Security and required distributions begin. Spreading conversions over several low-income years can keep more of the converted money in lower brackets.

Conversions also come up in withdrawal planning. Our guide to which accounts to withdraw from first in retirement explains how Roth money fits alongside taxable and pre-tax savings, and our explainer on how early retirees access retirement money before 59½ covers how some people convert in stages to build a supply of Roth money they can reach later.

Worked examples: what a conversion costs

The examples below use hypothetical tax rates and bracket sizes. They show federal income tax only; your state may tax the conversion too.

Example 1: The basic tax bill. Maya converts $20,000 from her traditional IRA, all of it pre-tax money. Her income already fills her bracket partway, and the whole $20,000 fits inside the 22% bracket. The extra federal tax is $20,000 × 0.22 = $4,400.

Example 2: Watching the top of your bracket. Devon's taxable income before converting is $70,000. In this example, his bracket ends $15,000 higher, at $85,000, and the next bracket is 24%. If he converts $15,000, all of it is taxed at 22%: $15,000 × 0.22 = $3,300. If he converts $25,000 instead, the first $15,000 costs $3,300 and the remaining $10,000 is taxed at 24%, or $2,400, for a total of $5,700. That's why many people size each conversion to "fill" a bracket rather than picking a round number. Remember that a conversion raises your income for the year, which can also affect other things tied to income, such as some credits and income-based premiums.

Example 3: Why withholding can backfire. Priya is 45 and converts $20,000 but asks her IRA provider to withhold 22% for taxes. Only $15,600 lands in the Roth. The $4,400 that was withheld wasn't converted, so it counts as a regular IRA distribution. She still owes income tax on the full $20,000, and because she's under 59½, the $4,400 may also face the 10% additional tax on early distributions unless an exception applies: $4,400 × 0.10 = $440. Paying the tax from savings outside the IRA avoids that cost and keeps the full $20,000 growing in the Roth. The IRS notes that an IRA distribution paid to you is subject to 10% withholding unless you elect out, so it's worth checking the withholding box on any conversion form.

Example 4: The pro-rata rule when you have after-tax money. Sam made $6,000 of nondeductible (after-tax) contributions over the years, so he has $6,000 of basis. His traditional IRAs are worth $60,000 in total. He wants to convert just $6,000, hoping it will be tax-free. It won't be. Form 8606 figures the nontaxable share using all of his traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances together, valued at the end of the year, plus the amount converted. If the rest stays at $54,000 on December 31, the math is $6,000 of basis ÷ ($54,000 + $6,000) = 10%. So $600 of his conversion is tax-free and $5,400 is taxable. Our guide to the backdoor Roth IRA explains why this rule matters so much for high earners.

Worked example: does converting pay off?

Example 5: Comparing tax rates now and later. Take $10,000 of pre-tax IRA money and a 22% tax rate today. Assume the investments double before retirement, whichever account they're in, and ignore state taxes.

If you convert, you pay $2,200 from savings today, and the Roth grows from $10,000 to $20,000, which you can later withdraw tax-free as a qualified distribution. You have $20,000.

If you don't convert, the traditional IRA grows to $20,000, and you keep the $2,200, which also doubles to $4,400 in a regular account. What happens next depends on your tax rate when you withdraw:

  • At 22% later: $20,000 × 0.78 = $15,600, plus $4,400 = $20,000. It's a tie.
  • At 12% later: $20,000 × 0.88 = $17,600, plus $4,400 = $22,000. Not converting comes out $2,000 ahead.
  • At 32% later: $20,000 × 0.68 = $13,600, plus $4,400 = $18,000. Converting comes out $2,000 ahead.

In real life, the growth on that $4,400 side account would usually be taxed along the way, which tilts the result slightly toward converting. The big lesson still holds: the decision mostly comes down to whether your tax rate is higher now or later.

The five-year rules

Roth IRAs have two different five-year clocks, and mixing them up is a common mistake.

The first clock decides whether earnings come out tax-free. The IRS Form 5329 instructions say a qualified distribution must be made after the five-year period beginning with the first tax year for which a contribution was made to a Roth IRA set up for your benefit, and it must also meet a condition such as being made on or after the date you reach age 59½.

The second clock applies to each conversion separately and matters if you're under 59½. The conversion itself isn't hit by the 10% additional tax. But if you withdraw converted money before that conversion's five-year period ends, the taxable part of it can be "recaptured" and charged the 10% additional tax, unless an exception applies. The IRS explains that an early distribution is generally allocated to your Roth IRA contributions first, then to your conversions and rollovers on a first-in, first-out basis.

Example 6: The conversion clock in action. Lena is 52 and converts $30,000 of pre-tax money. Her five-year period for that conversion starts on January 1 of the tax year she converts. Two years later, at 54, she withdraws $30,000. She has never made regular Roth contributions, so the whole withdrawal is treated as coming from that conversion. She already paid income tax on it, so no income tax is due again, but the 10% additional tax could apply: $30,000 × 0.10 = $3,000. If she waits until the five-year period ends, or until she turns 59½, that additional tax doesn't apply to the converted amount.

A step-by-step checklist before you convert

Work through these steps before each conversion, ideally late enough in the year to know your income well.

  1. Confirm the money is pre-tax and find your basis. Your past Form 8606 filings show any nondeductible contributions.
  2. Estimate your taxable income for the year without the conversion.
  3. Look up the current federal brackets on irs.gov and see how much room is left in your bracket.
  4. Check your state's tax rules for IRA conversions.
  5. Decide how you'll pay the tax. Using savings outside the IRA keeps the full amount working in the Roth.
  6. If you're required to take a minimum distribution, take it before converting.
  7. Ask your provider for a direct conversion and choose no withholding if you're paying the tax another way.
  8. Note the conversion's year in your records so you can track its five-year clock.
  9. Consider making estimated tax payments or adjusting paycheck withholding to cover the extra tax and avoid an underpayment surprise.

Common mistakes to avoid

Converting too much in one year is the most expensive error. A large conversion can push income into a much higher bracket, while several smaller conversions might have stayed in a lower one.

Another mistake is forgetting the pro-rata rule. If you have any after-tax money in traditional IRAs, you can't choose to convert only that part.

People also forget that conversions are permanent. Because they can't be recharacterized, converting right before a market drop means paying tax on value that has since fallen.

Finally, don't treat converted money as instantly available if you're under 59½. Each conversion has its own five-year clock for the 10% additional tax.

What to do next

Pull your most recent tax return and any Form 8606 filings, then sketch Example 2 with your own numbers: your taxable income, the top of your bracket and the amount you'd consider converting. If the math looks close or your situation is complicated, a tax professional can run a full projection, including state tax and any income-based costs.

Frequently asked questions

Is there an income limit for a Roth conversion?

No. The IRS says that regardless of your adjusted gross income, you may be able to convert amounts from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. Income limits apply to direct Roth contributions, not conversions.

Can I undo a Roth conversion?

No. Conversions made after 2017 can't be recharacterized back to a traditional IRA, so the tax is owed even if the investments later lose value.

Do I pay the 10% early withdrawal penalty on a Roth conversion?

The conversion itself isn't subject to the 10% additional tax. It can apply if you're under 59½ and withdraw the converted money before that conversion's five-year period ends, or to any amount withheld for taxes, unless an exception applies.

What form reports a Roth conversion?

Conversions are reported on Form 8606, Nondeductible IRAs, which also tracks any after-tax basis in your traditional IRAs.

Content on The Evergreen Edit is for educational and informational purposes only and is not individualized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Learn more.

Which money-saving habit will you focus on next?

This article is for educational purposes only and isn't personalized financial, tax or legal advice. Consider talking with a qualified professional about your situation.

Kiara Miller

Kiara Miller — Founder & Editor

Kiara Miller is the founder and editor of The Evergreen Edit. He has been doing independent finance research for two decades, is a tax preparer, and reviews every article before it's published.

More about Kiara →

Get smarter about your money.

Join readers who get money stories on their chosen topics, daily or as new articles post.

Which topics do you want in your inbox? Pick up to 3
Email frequency

We'll use your answers to send articles you care about and to plan new content. We never sell your info. Privacy Policy

Recommended reading