Skip to content
The Evergreen Edit
Save app to home screen
Investing

What Is Short Selling? How Shorting a Stock Works, Its Margin Rules and Short Squeezes, With Worked Examples

Short sellers borrow shares, sell them and hope to buy them back cheaper. Here is how shorting works, why losses have no ceiling, how margin calls and short squeezes happen, and the SEC rules that apply, with worked examples.

By Kiara Miller, Founder & Editor

Published · Last reviewed: · 9 min read

A green Wall St street sign on a pole in front of a glass office tower in New York City's financial district
Photo: Acediscovery via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

When a stock tumbles, some traders can make money on the way down. Here is how short sellers do it, and why it is one of the riskiest trades in investing.

What is short selling?

Short selling means selling shares you do not own, usually by borrowing them from your broker, in the hope of buying them back later at a lower price. If the price falls, you keep the difference. If it rises, you lose money, and in theory there is no limit to how much you can lose.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) describes a short sale as one that "generally involves the sale of a stock you do not own (or that you will borrow for delivery)," in its investor bulletin on short sales. Normal investing is called being "long": you buy first and sell later. Shorting flips the order. You sell first and buy later.

People short stocks for a few reasons, according to the SEC. Some expect a price to drop and want to profit from it. Others use a short position as a hedge, a kind of insurance that gains value if another stock they own falls. Market makers, the firms that keep trading flowing by standing ready to buy and sell, also sell short to meet unexpected buyer demand.

How does a short sale work, step by step?

A short sale happens in a margin account, a brokerage account that lets you borrow. Here is the usual sequence.

First, your broker finds shares for you to borrow. The SEC says brokers typically lend you the stock from their own inventory, from other customers' margin accounts or from another lender. Before your order goes through, SEC rules require the broker to have "reasonable grounds to believe that the security can be borrowed" so it can be delivered on time. This is called the locate requirement.

Second, the borrowed shares are sold at the current market price, and the cash from the sale sits in your account.

Third, while the position is open, you owe the lender. Your broker charges you interest or a fee to borrow the shares, and you are subject to margin rules. If the company pays a dividend, the SEC says "you must pay the dividend to the person or firm making the loan."

Finally, you close the trade by buying the same number of shares in the market and returning them. This is called covering your short. Your profit or loss is the difference between the price you sold at and the price you paid to buy back, minus borrowing costs, dividends you paid and trading fees.

Worked example 1: A short sale that works and one that does not

The SEC uses a simple example. Company A trades at $60 a share. You borrow and sell 100 shares, so $6,000 lands in your account.

If the price falls to $40, you buy 100 shares for $4,000 and return them. Your gain is $20 a share, or $2,000, before interest, fees and commissions.

If the price instead rises to $80, buying back 100 shares costs $8,000. You lose $20 a share, or $2,000, plus your costs.

So far that looks balanced. The difference shows up when prices move a lot.

Worked example 2: Why losses have no ceiling

When you buy a stock, the worst case is that it goes to zero and you lose what you put in. The SEC puts it this way: shorting "leaves an investor open to the possibility of unlimited losses," because a stock can keep rising.

Compare two investors who each start with a $60 stock.

The buyer purchases 100 shares for $6,000. If the company fails and the stock goes to $0, the buyer loses $6,000. That is the most they can lose.

The short seller sells 100 shares at $60. The best case is the stock going to $0, for a $6,000 gain. But if the stock climbs to $150, buying back costs $15,000, a $9,000 loss. At $300, the loss is $24,000. There is no price at which the loss stops growing.

That lopsided risk is why short selling is usually a tool for experienced traders, and why brokers watch short positions closely.

Worked example 3: Margin requirements and margin calls

Because short sellers owe shares back, regulators require them to keep extra money in the account as a cushion. Under FINRA Rule 4210, the minimum ongoing cushion, called maintenance margin, for a short stock trading at $5 or more is "$5.00 per share or 30 percent of the current market value, whichever amount is greater." For stocks under $5, it is $2.50 per share or 100% of the market value, whichever is greater. The same rule requires at least $2,000 of equity in a margin account, and brokers may set stricter "house" requirements of their own.

Here is how that plays out. Say you short 100 shares at $60 and your account holds $15,000 in total: the $6,000 from the sale plus $9,000 of your own cash. In a short account, your equity is that cash balance minus the current value of the shares you owe.

At $60, the shares you owe are worth $6,000. Equity is $15,000 minus $6,000, or $9,000. FINRA's minimum is the greater of $500 ($5 times 100 shares) or $1,800 (30% of $6,000), so $1,800. You are well covered.

At $80, the shares you owe are worth $8,000. Equity drops to $7,000, and the minimum rises to $2,400. You are still fine.

The danger point comes when equity equals 30% of the shares' value. With $15,000 in the account and 100 shares short, that happens at about $115.38 a share, where the shares are worth $11,538, equity is $3,462 and 30% of $11,538 is also about $3,462. Above that price, you would face a margin call, a demand to add money or close the position. FINRA notes that brokers may sell out an account to cover a shortfall, so you may not get a say in when your position is closed. Many brokers set higher requirements than this FINRA floor, so a call could come sooner.

Worked example 4: The hidden costs of staying short

Short positions cost money to hold, even when the price does not move.

Borrowing fees and interest vary by broker and by how hard a stock is to borrow. As a hypothetical, if your broker charged 5% a year to borrow $6,000 worth of stock, holding the position for three months would cost about $75 ($6,000 times 5%, divided by 4). Hard-to-borrow stocks can cost far more.

Dividends add up, too. If the company pays a $0.50-per-share dividend while you are short 100 shares, you owe the lender $50. A stock that goes nowhere for a year can still leave a short seller with a loss after these costs.

What is a short squeeze?

The SEC defines a short squeeze as "the pressure on short sellers to cover their positions as a result of sharp price increases or difficulty in borrowing the security the sellers are short."

Here is how it can spiral. A heavily shorted stock jumps on good news. Short sellers start losing money and get margin calls, so they buy shares to close out. That buying pushes the price higher, which squeezes the next group of short sellers, who buy too. The price can rise far faster than the news alone would explain. Going back to example 3, a stock that runs from $60 to $120 would push that account past its roughly $115 danger point and could force a buyback at a large loss. Crypto sees squeezes too, as in our story on Bitcoin climbing back above $80,000 as short sellers were forced out.

The SEC says deliberately manipulating a stock's price or availability to trigger a squeeze is illegal.

What rules govern short selling?

Most short selling is legal, and the SEC lists providing liquidity among its uses; only abusive practices are illegal. The main rulebook is Regulation SHO, which took effect in 2005. According to the SEC's summary of Regulation SHO, it does four main things.

Marking: every sell order must be marked "long," "short" or "short exempt," so regulators can track short sales.

Locate: before a short sale, the broker must have reasonable grounds to believe the shares can be borrowed and delivered on time, and must document it.

Close-out: if a short seller fails to deliver shares, the broker generally must close out that failure by the start of regular trading on the day after settlement.

Circuit breaker: under Rule 201, if a stock falls at least 10% in one day, a price test limits short sales for the rest of that day and the following day, unless an exception applies. For example, if a stock closed at $50 yesterday and drops to $45 today, the restriction kicks in.

You may also hear about naked short selling. That is selling short without borrowing the shares, or arranging to borrow them, in time for delivery within the standard one-day settlement period. The SEC says this is not always a violation, since market makers sometimes need to do it, but abusive naked shorting is illegal.

Should everyday investors short stocks?

Many long-term investors never short a stock, and buy-and-hold investing does not require it. For a 401(k) or IRA saver, short selling is mostly worth understanding because it explains some sharp market moves, like a sudden squeeze or a plunge driven by bearish bets.

If you are curious about betting on a decline, compare the risks of other tools first. Buying a put option, for instance, caps your loss at what you paid, as our options basics guide explains. Short selling has no such cap, adds borrowing costs, and can force you out of a trade at the worst moment. If you ever do short a stock, know your broker's house margin rules and borrowing fees before you place the order.

Frequently asked questions

How much can you lose short selling a stock?

In theory, there is no limit. Because a stock's price can keep rising, the cost of buying back the shares can grow far beyond the money you received when you sold them short.

What is the margin requirement for a short sale?

Under FINRA Rule 4210, the minimum maintenance requirement for a short stock priced at $5 or more is the greater of $5 per share or 30% of its current market value. Brokers can set higher requirements.

What triggers a short squeeze?

A short squeeze happens when a heavily shorted stock rises sharply or becomes hard to borrow. Short sellers rush to buy shares to close their positions, which can push the price even higher.

Is naked short selling illegal?

Not always. The SEC says naked short selling is not necessarily a violation, but abusive naked shorting is illegal, and Regulation SHO requires brokers to locate shares before most short sales.

Content on The Evergreen Edit is for educational and informational purposes only and is not individualized financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Learn more.

Compound growth estimate

Estimated total

$17,175

Your contributions

$13,000

This is an estimate, not a prediction. Monthly compounding; taxes, fees and inflation are excluded.

This article is for educational purposes only and isn't personalized financial, tax or legal advice. Consider talking with a qualified professional about your situation.

Kiara Miller

Kiara Miller — Founder & Editor

Kiara Miller is the founder and editor of The Evergreen Edit. He has been doing independent finance research for two decades, is a tax preparer, and reviews every article before it's published.

More about Kiara →

Get smarter about your money.

Join readers who get money stories on their chosen topics, daily or as new articles post.

Which topics do you want in your inbox? Pick up to 3
Email frequency

We'll use your answers to send articles you care about and to plan new content. We never sell your info. Privacy Policy

Recommended reading